Proper Pie Menu (Update 2025)

Proper Pie in Richmond, VA offers a diverse menu ranging from savory pies like Steak & Cheese to the decadent Sour Cream & Wild Blueberry sweet pie. Customers rave about the divine pie crust and the high-quality ingredients used in each pie. The savory options cater to all tastes, including vegan and vegetarian choices. The Banoffee pie, with layers of toffee, bananas, and whipped cream on an Anzac biscuit crust, is a must-try. The vegan Mock Turtle pie surprises with its Oreo crust and almond butter mousse filling. Proper Pie's pastry is hailed for its golden brown firmness and heavenly taste. With friendly service and unique New Zealand-style pies, Proper Pie is a must-visit spot for pie enthusiasts. Next time you're in Church Hill, don't miss the chance to indulge in Proper Pie's delightful creations.